Defining feature of good golf architecture? It is not length

This content was first published in Golf Journala quarterly printed edition exclusively for USGA members. Being among the first to get Golf Journal And to learn how you can provide a strong future for the game, Become a member of the USA today!

“Nothing revolves like a ball.” This is what a friend withdrew as he looked at my first trick from the greenery to the 13th hole in San Francisco’s California Golf Club. While I wasn’t having fun at the time, those words stuck with me as they underline the challenge of the game – getting a round ball to bring and stop where you want!

A course needs a certain amount of length to force players to hit each club in their bag but the length is empathy NO Definition features of good golf course architecture. Which raises the question: which design elements challenge athletic people with powerful, powerful oscillations? What characteristics are inserted inside their heads, immersed in their nerves, and create indecision?

The answer is that the course must remove the game from a simple physical pursuit and make it a mental, as well as asking questions that are not asked in the range of practice. When a course does this, it is amazing how often the titans of the game rise to the top.

The most obvious design feature that identifies the best player is excellent greens. Consider five open US cornerstone sites: Pinehurst no. 2, Oakmont, Winged, Shinnecock hillsAND Oakland Hills South. If someone asked me to list the top five greens groups in the country, this may be my answer. Throw in them in Augusta NationalAnd it is clear that large greens are the final protection of every course.

Green circle also dictate what kind of recovery shooting are available. The more interesting and diverse opportunities, the better. Pinehurst No. 2 is famous for the questions you ask after your ball comes to rest at the base of its driven greens. Present with a narrow lie in the short grass, you can try any number of recovery shooting, from a pitch or chip to a hybrid iron, with hood or perhaps even struck as Martin Kaymer did for such a great effect on US Open 2014.

By providing such options, the player now has to foil things in the country – and this is where things get interesting. And it is done glamor When the first attempt does not go as planned. Bryson Dechambeau won 2024 US Open for all kinds of reasons, including its length, but its short game Sunday’s ability in Pinehurst No. 2 was especially the other world.

Sometimes, the smallest features can have a great impact. Get the street hole bunker in Old course in St. Andrews And how she collects on balls. Once you are in it, this pit of approximately 5 x 3 yard does not guarantee a good attitude or clean pace. This uncertainty is worrying for the player again on the road. The same can be said for those narrow bunkers, of the Greenside trenches Erin Hills This made the players notice in 2025 US women.

No doubt about this: the closer you reach a green, the nerve becomes every shot, and the more subtlety plays a role. And the last thing a player in the quarrel wants is partial nervous shots. Knowing this, the people responsible for creating a course for an elite competition are obliged to seek such shots!

Take the 2nd hole of 346-Oborri in Oakmont-Analitics say to drive the ball as close to the green as possible, but this modest length par 4 played in the first half of the most difficult holes to open 2025 US Open because it insists on looking for an accurate partial blow. The same for the 15th with the 260 Oborri in Erin Hills in the third round of Open women when she played as the second most harsh hole. She forced the players to make a decision: to rest or go to a challenging place of the right hole. To quote Bob Jones, “you swing your best when you have the least things to think about.”

However, before reaching a green, you must navigate past obstacles. Approximate is certainly an important consideration because if you can’t get clean clubs in the ball, then you are not in control. The harsh density is a determinant of humor. Remember Nicklaus using a 1-i-i-i-i-i-i-i-i-i-i-i-i i i lihfield in the 1966 open championship to avoid hay? One person who appreciates the Golf story is Tiger Woods, and he used a similar strategy at Royal Liverpool in 2006 when he executed his low stinger in perfection over those rounded, soft roads. Thick tough makes the player discuss if the driver is the appropriate game from Tee – and this is a decision he does not face most weeks.

Golf is about the interaction of the ball and the land, and how the architect catches the land inside the hole helps to form that challenge. An opposite road to Kamber as No. 4 in the Olympic Club Lake – its right oscillations on the left, but the slopes of the right roads left to the right – always beds, partly because it’s a rarity.

The same as the glorious rumpled streets in St. Andrews. Such a terrestrial movement strengthens constant tear, rather than for your attitude and placement. Flat courses simply cannot compete with courses in interesting terrestrial forms.

And guess what else forces the player to make real -time adjustments? The wind. While people have no control over that element, they have to fly the ball and play knackdown shots are fabulous ways to find out who is in full control of their swing – and who is not. How do you know if you will lower a top 10 meters less than a green or 30 when will it go down? Gamma does not answer such questions.

This response depends on the durability of the terrain under the foot. Fairways and extremely strong greens means that the player cedon some control of where their (round) ball stops. The surfaces of the firm playing are Supporting an ideal test. Back-to-back 2014 US Open and US Women Open in Pinehurst will be forever a testimony about it. Otherwise, remember all the rain in the US Open 2011 at the Congress? Rory Mcilroy hit the course with his driver for excellent effect, and his total of 268 is still the lowest winning result in Open US history.

In addition to the street contours, man -made obstacles must be included in the right ways to make the player think. Bunkers steep, like those in Muirfield, Royal Lytham & St. Annes and many other classic tests, identify who is traveling well.

Penalty areas have clearly received the player’s attention and have provided attractive actions since the dawn of the game. 5 -In Oak Hill will always be one of Donald Ross’s best creations based on how he included a central stream on the right side of the road and on the left to green. However, such traits, while they can remove the life of a ball, also reduce the art of recovery. In the 1980s and 1990s, the 16th and 16th hole in the Oakland Hills bending towards a lake was considered by many as his “signature” hole. The tastes and advantages have changed, and for those who estimate that they are able to play agile recovery shots, no. 16 may not be ranked even in the first half of the holes of that powerful course.

In fact, it is worth noting that as you see many lakes and ponds in PGA Tour stops, the pages of the open American cornerstone rarely show them. Provide USGA credit to prioritize other obstacles to ubiquitous water features.

As for the trees, one of the most iconic holes of the game rests on them, not that you would know it because the rocks and the hog ocean in the spotlight. I am referring to no. 18at Pebble Beach. Outside Pairift make the hole an attractive driving test while the single tree greenhouse makes to count your shooting. In other words, imagine 18 in Pebble without those three trees and holes would be much less interesting. Trees are seen as an enemy of the conditions of the game firms, but those boldly placed like those in the Pebble are a great way to ask players to form shots and/or control their trajectory.

Golfists want to assert the predominance of a course, and the course obligation is to fight again. Every thing that prey in the player’s mind and creates indecision-from strong surfaces in punishment areas well placed up to large greens-turns the test into equal mental and physical parts.

Sometimes players – and you know the names – enjoy the challenge and rarely tighten. Most often, suspicion crawls and over 72 holes follow. As in life, the way you treat the worst moments does a lot to determine your character. And this is what the best events, played in the best courses, are behind: Tell us that you are made.